By Malice Intended of Planet Ill

In the Borough of Brooklyn, three cops are fast approaching their breaking point. Detective Salvatore “Sal” Procida (Ethan Hawke) is a family man whose salary as a cop cannot cover his financial obligations. Detective Clarence “Tango” Butler (Don Cheadle) is an undercover cop whose loyalty to drug dealer Casanova “Caz” Phillips (Wesley Snipes) makes an already difficult assignment nearly impossible. Officer Eddie Dugan (Richard Gere) is a burned out uniform cop who is mere days from retirement. None of these men know each other, yet their paths will inevitably cross as the walls close in on them.

Brooklyn’s Finest is director Antoine Fuqua’s first hard boiled cop drama since the immensely popular and Oscar winning Training Day. It covers much of the same territory, albeit from various points of view. It follows three separate plot lines that converge in the final act, and unlike its predecessor it does not feature a respected actor playing against type. It’s a more traditional and low key affair.

Visually the film goes for intensity and immediacy. Tight close ups and medium shots suggest a suffocating environment. The action alternates from congested city streets to the rooftops and hallways of the Van Dyke houses in Brownsville. These characters live in a self contained world, both internally and externally. Patrick Murguia’s cinematography frames Brooklyn as a claustrophobic labyrinth and harkens back to the films of the 1970’s. This is the grittiest the Big Apple has looked in quite a while.

Writer Michael C. Martin provides the characters with dialogue that surpasses the usual tough guy banter associated with films of this type. The excessively profane exchanges suggest the fragile nature of the alpha male posturing that dominates this world. All of these men are in a line of work that requires them to stay “in character” at all times. The words these characters speak are meant to maintain the façade and hide weakness. Michael C. Martin gives us cops who struggle to hold their fabricated personas together.

Brooklyn’s Finest maintains an aura of gritty realism and plausibility almost to the very end. Unfortunately, predictable patterns make themselves increasingly evident as the film moves along. This ultimately undermines the dramatic structure and robs the final act of its visceral punch. The conclusion feels like the culmination of plot contrivances rather than a powerful story that develops organically. It is the very definition of poeticism.

The earnest performances imbue the characters with a sense of empathy. Don Cheadle is sometimes less than convincing as the frazzled Tango, but his commitment to the role eventually wears us down. Wesley Snipes reveals an unexpected side to his onscreen persona. Casanova is a far cry from New Jack City’s narcissistic and ruthless Nino Brown. He is a weathered veteran, made cautious by his years of hustling. Ethan Hawke infuses every scene he’s in with nervous energy.

One has to admire the intentions of Brooklyn’s Finest. It seeks to move beyond the more titillating and superficial elements of the standard police procedural. Its reach exceeds its grasp, and its adherence to cop movie conventions nearly does it in. Thankfully, its strong points keep it from buckling under completely. Though less than perfect, Brooklyn’s Finest is not without merit or interest. It is a satisfactory, if not exceptional, entry into a tried and true genre. 3.25 out of 5

Check out more reviews and articles at Planet Ill:


  1. In your last next to last paragraph you run through Cheadle, Snipes and Hawke’s characters/performances but you didn’t mention Gere’s Eddie Dugan.


    He was the least dynamic and the least likable of the three 4 headliners.

    While I can’t find a flaw in Gere’s performance as Dugan, I do believe he was miscast.

    I have my own review of Brooklyn’s Finest:

    Thanks for your review, Hope you will take a look at mine.


  2. Hi,

    We’ve browsed through your reviews and thought that they are really original and interesting! We would like to invite you to publish your reviews on, which provides an alternative platform for promising movie reviewers to showcase their talents. In addition, you’ll find a growing community of bloggers who share the same passion for excellent movies! Based on the merit of your reviews, we intend to offer you exclusive publishing privileges on our website!

    7tavern Team

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s